30th March 2021
20th March 2020
13th March 2020
29th January 2019
17th November 2020
1st January 2020
20th November 2017
16th May 2017
16th February 2021
9th September 2020
3rd September 2020
22nd July 2020
17th February 2021
7th December 2020
20th January 2020
14th January 2020
26th April 2021
4th February 2021
30th May 2020
25th February 2020
25th April 2021
12th February 2021
31st May 2020
16th April 2019
9th August 2020
26th March 2019
2nd June 2018
19th June 2020
13th December 2019
20th November 2020
20th February 2020
17th August 2014
18th July 2019
28th January 2021
10th January 2021
31st October 2020
15th November 2014
8th March 2020
7th August 2018
27th December 2016
4th May 2014
29th September 2020
24th September 2020
26th July 2020
12th June 2020
15th October 2018
26th June 2018
13th June 2017
4th January 2016
1 in every 6th Indian suffers from some form of mental illness – the World Health Organisation estimates that India will suffer a $1 trillion economic loss due to unaddressed mental health conditions between 2012 and 2030. At Lightbox, we are in the business of understanding the Indian consumer and her problems, and then investing in the best solutions to counter these problems.
Have you ever woken up in the morning with a sense of dread that is unshakeable? What about paralyzing anxiety where you know you need to get started on your day, but you just. physically. can’t.?
You, dear reader, may not have experienced the above, but I, along with roughly 200 million other Indians have. 1 in every 6th Indian suffers from some form of mental illness. As someone who lives with low-lying anxiety, I know how insidious and debilitating a mental health disorder can be (despite having only experienced low-level symptoms of the most common mental illness).
Everything that happens to our bodies, starts with our minds. I never truly understood this until I felt like I did not have sufficient control over my own mind. Extrapolate that feeling 200 million times over and you can only imagine the negative externalities that unaddressed mental illnesses have had on our collective consciousness. In case you need data to grasp the gravity of this problem – the WHO estimates that India will suffer a $1 trillion economic loss due to unaddressed mental health conditions between 2012 and 2030.
Figure 1: India is the Suicide Capital of the World
At Lightbox, we are in the business of understanding the Indian consumer and her problems, and then investing in the best solutions to counter these problems. The enormous gap between those who are in need of mental health care and those that receive care (ie. “the treatment gap”), at a high level of clinical excellence, is probably one of THE biggest problems we face as a country. It is one that we, as a fund, are committed to understanding, in order to find and back a company that is solving for the crux of the issues at hand – how do we not only reduce the treatment gap but also help cure mental illness at scale?
In our minds, it is not enough to expand access to mental healthcare, but rather, it is imperative to create products and services that can treat mental illness, while adhering to a high standard of clinical efficacy. We believe a curative solution is the way forward because most mental illnesses can, in fact, be managed. The WHO stated “despite the chronic and long-term nature of some mental disorders, over 80% of people with schizophrenia can be free of relapses at the end of one year of treatment with antipsychotic drugs combined with family intervention, and 60% of people with depression can recover with proper combination of antidepressant drugs and psychotherapy.”
The case for curative solutions:
Consumer psychology points to the fact that “messaging” alone won’t push consumers to choose preventive healthcare measures; many need to understand the risks first. Through our research, we realized that adoption of preventive healthcare is often hinged on 1) raising awareness, 2) helping identify mental illnesses and 3) providing a curative solution after identification of the mental disorder.
Therefore, we believe that “cure-ation” (yes, I just made up this word) comes before prevention. It is universally accepted that if you break your arm, you can go to a doctor who is likely to help the healing process, and hopefully fix it. This is a curative solution – even if the doctor didn’t prescribe you medication, he is not merely placing a band-aid on a broken arm (if he is, please change your doctor). Consumers have grown accustom to putting their trust, and therefore their health, in the hands of these widely accepted treatments.
The rise of technology and scientific advancement has also made illnesses, that were at one point fatal, curable today – tetanus, rabies, polio. Over time, the fear and the stigma associated with these diseases have also dissipated. Those who unfortunately contract these diseases no longer have to retreat from society, they are, ideally (and hopefully), able to get the treatment they need. Once these curative treatments were developed, then preventive measures became part of the solution. Similarly, in India, where those who are mentally ill are often forced to retreat into the shadows of society, clinically identifying and then curing mental illnesses needs to be more universally accepted and understood. Only then will a large part of the population take preventive measures more seriously.
Warning! Difficult market dynamics ahead:
Clearly, there is an urgent need for a new solution in India. However, there are innumerable hurdles that afflict the market, which will need to be overcome by companies hoping to create wide-scale impact in this space. These roadblocks can be grouped into 3 buckets – lack of awareness, lack of access, and lack of quality of care – and will be expanded upon further below.
Stigma against publicly addressing mental illnesses is often spoken about in the context of Indian mental health, so I am not going to touch upon it in much detail here. What is less known however is how the regulatory environment has led to a lack of awareness and understanding of the issues at hand. India inherited some colonial era laws related to mental health called The Lunacy Act of 1912 that has contributed to the stigma we have against those suffering from mental illnesses. This Act essentially criminalized those who were mentally unwell. Although the government established an updated version in 1987 called the Mental Health Act, it still criminalized attempted suicide.
It was only in 2017, with the updated Mental Healthcare Act, that the government decriminalized attempted suicide and provisioned to protect the rights of the mentally ill. Keeping this long history in mind, it is no wonder that it takes up to 4 years for the average Indian to seek treatment for mental disorders after experiencing first symptoms.
Patients in India are woefully undertreated and underserved. 85% of patients who need access to mental healthcare services are unable to receive care. This is because India has less 5,000 mental health professionals (for a population of 1BN+, shocking I know). The WHO recommends 1 psychiatrist per 8,000 people; in India we have 1 per 333,333 people. Moreover, we only have 43 government-run mental hospitals, which translates to 3 psychiatrist beds per 100,000 people, while Malaysia and China have 25 and 24, respectively.
Due to the lack of supply, high-quality mental health care is offered at a prohibitively high cost and only few can afford it. This is because 70-80% of healthcare expenditure is funded out of consumer pockets because of the government’s abysmal healthcare budget, and the millions that remain uninsured. In fact, the government, despite allotting $6MM to the National Mental Health Program in FY19 only spent $650K of the funds available.
Figure 2. Healthcare professionals per 1MM people
To add to all the aforementioned problems, practicing mental health is a poorly regulated field and those who do get access to treatment may come to realize that there are no standard operating procedures across therapists. Patients are often left to navigate the care process alone. Dr. Soumitra Pathare, the director of The Center for Mental Health Law and Policy, often speaks about how there is no particular set of qualifications you need to call yourself a therapist, and although clinical psychologists need a license to practice, there is no standardization of treatment and it is difficult to judge who is abiding by clinical excellence.
When beginning your journey to receive high quality mental health care, a psychologist will work with a psychiatrist to make sure that your diagnosis and treatment plans are in sync. They both should aim to take accountability across the care spectrum – from discovery and treatment to relapse management. Currently, there are only a handful of offline clinics that operate this way, bringing to light how poorly coordinated and fragmented the current care process is.
I know what you’re thinking…enough about the sad state of the market… let’s hear some solutions!!
Given the market dynamics mentioned above, it is clear that the system we have in place is unable to deliver effective outcomes, and provide a structured care plan for consumers. Unfortunately, this leaves the onus of managing post-care treatment on patients and their families.
Keeping this in mind, we set out to explore companies looking to solve these pressing issues. Based on our research, we knew that the most important yardstick to measure any mental health company is against the outcomes they are delivering. We looked at companies across four different business models, and have collated some of our learnings below.
Figure 3: Market Map
So, none of the solutions above hit a home run for us. Now what?
We want to help solve the messy, tangled, difficult questions that naturally arise when you look for solutions in this industry: how do we create curative and clinically excellent mental healthcare businesses? How do we ensure that we are building programs with a customer-first mindset? Can we build a curative program that is preventative as well?
We may not have the answers to all the questions above yet, but what we do know is that providing customer-centric, curative mental health care requires a company to build for the entire “care continuum”. The care continuum is the process of following the patient from “preventive care, through medical incidents, rehabilitation and maintenance.” Depending on the patient’s needs, a company would provide a variety of solutions at different points in his or her healthcare journey, and this coordinated effort results in better outcomes for patients.
Figure 4: The Care Continuum
This flow, from discovery to treatment, maintenance and eventually prevention of other mental illnesses, has been clinically proved to be an effective way of delivering health care. However, building and managing this process is difficult, and requires a thoughtful, innovative approach.
Although we may not have found the best solutions yet, we are excited to continue on our quest to look for companies that are meeting their customers wherever they are in their journey to get well; a company that is providing touchpoints of care across the spectrum and building with an outcome-oriented approach in mind. A healthcare company that builds with an emphasis on the care.